Securing an H-1B visa requires careful preparation. The petition needs to clearly establish that the offered position qualifies as a specialty occupation, that the beneficiary meets the position’s requirements, and that the employment arrangement and supporting documentation satisfy the applicable requirements.
A Request for Evidence (RFE) can arise when USCIS determines that the evidence submitted with an H-1B petition does not sufficiently establish eligibility. USCIS has identified several areas that commonly lead to RFEs, including specialty occupation requirements, the Labor Condition Application (LCA) and wage level, the beneficiary’s qualifications, and the employer-employee relationship and qualifying work.
Preparing these areas carefully before filing can help identify potential weaknesses and provide a clearer record for USCIS to review.
Quick Answer: What Can Make an H-1B Petition Stronger?
An H-1B petition should connect the position, the beneficiary’s qualifications, the required wage, and the actual employment arrangement through consistent and relevant evidence.
Four areas deserve particular attention:
- Specialty occupation: The evidence should explain why the position requires specialized knowledge and a bachelor’s degree or higher in a directly related specialty, or its equivalent.
- Wage and LCA: The certified LCA should properly correspond to the offered position, including the appropriate occupational classification and wage level.
- Education and qualifications: The beneficiary’s education and, where applicable, qualifying experience should be appropriately evaluated against the requirements of the position.
- Employer-employee relationship and qualifying work: The petition should establish the employment relationship and show that the beneficiary will perform qualifying specialty occupation work.
Each H-1B case depends on its particular facts and documentation. There is no single document that guarantees approval or prevents an RFE.
1. Establish the Specialty Occupation Clearly
One of the central issues in an H-1B petition is whether the offered position qualifies as a specialty occupation.
The evidence should establish that the position requires specialized knowledge and normally requires at least a U.S. bachelor’s degree or its equivalent in a specific specialty directly related to the position.
USCIS has specifically advised petitioners to explain how the beneficiary’s duties relate to and require knowledge obtained through a particular degree or set of related degrees.
A general job title by itself may not adequately explain the specialized nature of the position. The petition should instead provide a detailed description of the actual duties, responsibilities, required knowledge, and academic qualifications.
What Evidence Can Support the Specialty Occupation?
Depending on the circumstances, supporting evidence may include:
- A detailed description of the position’s duties
- Explanation of the specialized knowledge required
- The employer’s stated educational requirements
- Relevant job postings
- Evidence concerning the employer’s historical hiring practices
- Industry information concerning comparable positions
- Documentation explaining the relationship between the position and the required field of study
- An expert opinion letter from a qualified professional, where appropriate
USCIS’s current RFE guidance notes that a job posting can also be useful evidence when it identifies the position’s education, experience, and skill requirements. USCIS recommends that such evidence include information such as the source and date of the posting when used to support the petition.
The goal is to create a clear connection between the job duties, the specialized knowledge required, and the academic background expected of the person performing the job.
2. Make Sure the Wage and LCA Correspond to the Position
Wage documentation is another important part of an H-1B petition.
Under Department of Labor requirements, the employer generally must pay the higher of the applicable prevailing wage or the actual wage paid to similarly qualified employees for the specific employment.
The Labor Condition Application also needs to properly correspond to the position described in the H-1B petition.
USCIS’s current RFE guidance specifically identifies situations where the SOC occupational classification or selected wage level does not properly correspond to the position as a potential issue. USCIS also explains that selecting a Level I wage does not automatically result in an RFE. The concern can arise when the position’s requirements and duties indicate that the selected wage level does not properly correspond to the offered position.
What Should Be Reviewed?
Before filing, the petition should be reviewed for consistency among:
- The job title
- Job duties
- SOC occupational classification
- Required education
- Required experience
- Required skills
- Wage level
- Offered salary
- Work location
- LCA information
- Supporting documentation
Where the position involves specialized or unusual duties, the petition should explain why the selected occupational classification and wage information accurately correspond to the actual position.
A prevailing wage determination or appropriate wage documentation may also help establish why the selected classification and wage are appropriate. USCIS identifies such documentation as potentially useful evidence when the wage level or occupational classification requires additional explanation.
3. Address the Beneficiary’s Education and Qualifications
The beneficiary’s education should be reviewed in relation to the requirements of the H-1B position.
Potential questions can arise when the beneficiary has:
- A foreign degree
- A three-year degree
- A generalized degree
- Education from an institution or program requiring additional review
- Incomplete education
- A combination of education and professional experience
- Academic credentials that do not appear to directly correspond to the requirements of the position
The important issue is not simply whether the beneficiary has a degree. The petition should establish how the beneficiary’s academic and professional background meets the requirements of the specific specialty occupation.
Credential Evaluation Can Help Clarify Foreign Education
When a beneficiary has foreign education, an appropriate credential evaluation can help explain how the academic credentials compare with U.S. educational standards.
The evaluation should consider the beneficiary’s academic background and its relationship to the requirements of the offered position.
Where the applicable H-1B requirements permit education and qualifying professional experience to be considered together, the supporting analysis should clearly identify the education and experience being relied upon and explain how they establish the required equivalency.
This is particularly important when the beneficiary’s academic background does not follow a conventional four-year U.S. bachelor’s degree path.
A credential evaluation should not be treated as a substitute for the complete petition record. It should work together with transcripts, diplomas, employment documentation, job requirements, and other relevant evidence.
4. Establish the Employer-Employee Relationship and Qualifying Work
The employer-employee relationship is another area that can receive close attention during H-1B adjudication.
A petition should provide evidence showing the employer’s continuing need for the beneficiary and the employer’s relationship with the employee.
This is particularly important when the beneficiary will work at a third-party location or through a consulting or staffing arrangement.
USCIS states that petitioners in third-party worksite situations must establish, among other requirements, that the beneficiary will be employed in a specialty occupation and that an employer-employee relationship will exist for the requested validity period. USCIS guidance also addresses the importance of specific, non-speculative qualifying work.
Third-Party Worksites Require Careful Documentation
When a beneficiary will work for or at a third-party organization, the petition should clearly explain the work arrangement.
Relevant evidence can include documentation concerning:
- The specific project or work to be performed
- The nature of the services
- The beneficiary’s role
- The work location
- The duration of the assignment
- The relationship between the petitioner and other parties involved
- The employer’s continuing authority over the beneficiary
USCIS has stated that third-party worksite arrangements can make it more difficult to establish whether the beneficiary will actually perform specialty occupation work and whether the required employer-employee relationship exists.
At the same time, current USCIS guidance should be applied carefully. Older guidance concerning itineraries and specific day-to-day assignments has changed over time. USCIS rescinded certain prior itinerary-related policy guidance and clarified that a petitioner is not required to document the beneficiary’s specific day-to-day assignments simply to establish eligibility. The petitioner must still establish eligibility under the applicable statutory, regulatory, and current policy requirements.
For this reason, third-party worksite cases should be reviewed using current USCIS requirements rather than relying solely on older checklists or historical guidance.
How These Areas Work Together
The strongest petitions present a consistent story across the entire record.
For example, consider a position described as requiring specialized knowledge in a particular technology field.
The petition should be consistent about:
| Area | What Should Be Clear |
|---|---|
| Position | The actual duties and responsibilities |
| Specialty occupation | Why the duties require specialized knowledge |
| Education | Why the required degree or equivalent is related to the position |
| Beneficiary | How the beneficiary meets the stated requirements |
| Wage | Why the selected wage and LCA correspond to the position |
| Employment | Who employs and controls the beneficiary |
| Work arrangement | Where and for whom the qualifying work will be performed |
Problems can arise when these elements do not align.
For example, a petition may describe highly specialized duties but list educational requirements that appear unrelated to those duties. Similarly, the position description, SOC classification, wage level, and LCA should not contradict one another.
A careful pre-filing review can identify these inconsistencies before the petition reaches USCIS.
Common Mistakes That Can Create Questions
Several documentation problems can make it harder to establish H-1B eligibility.
Generic Job Descriptions
A generic description may not explain what the beneficiary will actually do or why specialized academic knowledge is required.
Weak Connection Between Degree and Position
Simply listing a degree requirement may not be enough. The petition should explain how the position’s duties require knowledge associated with the stated field of study.
Inconsistent Wage Information
The wage, LCA, job duties, occupational classification, and position requirements should tell the same story.
Incomplete Education Analysis
When foreign, nontraditional, or combined education and experience is involved, the record should clearly explain how the beneficiary meets the educational requirements.
Insufficient Evidence of Qualifying Work
For third-party work arrangements, the petition should provide appropriate evidence establishing the employment arrangement and qualifying work.
Relying on One Document
No single document should be expected to establish every element of eligibility. The petition should present evidence that supports the different requirements as a consistent whole.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an H-1B petition still be approved if USCIS issues an RFE?
Yes. An RFE is a request for additional evidence or information. It does not by itself mean that the petition will be denied. The response should address the issues identified by USCIS and provide relevant supporting evidence.
Does selecting a Level I wage automatically cause an H-1B RFE?
No. USCIS’s current RFE guidance specifically states that it will not issue an RFE simply because a Level I wage has been selected. A concern can arise when the selected wage level does not properly correspond to the position’s requirements, duties, or other information in the petition.
Can a foreign degree be used for an H-1B petition?
A foreign degree can potentially satisfy the educational requirement when it is determined to be equivalent to the required U.S. degree or otherwise meets the applicable H-1B requirements. The appropriate analysis depends on the beneficiary’s education, the position requirements, and the applicable rules.
Can professional experience be considered with education for H-1B purposes?
In certain H-1B situations, qualifying education and professional experience may be considered together when determining educational equivalency. The specific facts and applicable requirements need to be reviewed carefully.
Does an H-1B petition involving a third-party worksite require contracts?
There is no simple rule that every H-1B petition must include a complete chain of third-party contracts. USCIS states that contracts or legal agreements may be considered as evidence when evaluating issues such as the employer-employee relationship and qualifying specialty occupation work.
What should an employer review before filing an H-1B petition?
The employer should review the position, job duties, educational requirements, beneficiary’s qualifications, LCA, wage information, work location, and employment arrangement for consistency. Additional review may be appropriate when the case involves foreign education, nontraditional educational backgrounds, third-party worksites, or unusual position requirements.
Key Takeaways
A well-prepared H-1B petition should clearly connect the position, the beneficiary’s qualifications, the wage information, and the employment arrangement.
The main areas to review include:
- Specialty occupation: Explain why the position requires specialized knowledge and the relevant academic background.
- Wage and LCA: Make sure the occupational classification and wage level properly correspond to the position.
- Education: Establish how the beneficiary’s education and, where applicable, qualifying experience meet the position’s requirements.
- Employer-employee relationship: Provide appropriate evidence of the employment arrangement and the employer’s relationship with the beneficiary.
- Qualifying work: Particularly in third-party worksite cases, establish that the beneficiary will perform qualifying specialty occupation work.
Reviewing these areas before filing can help identify documentation gaps and inconsistencies that may otherwise become issues during USCIS adjudication.
Conclusion
Preparing an H-1B petition involves more than collecting standard forms and supporting documents. The evidence should present a consistent explanation of the position, the beneficiary’s qualifications, the required wage, and the employment relationship.
Specialty occupation requirements, wage and LCA information, educational qualifications, and employer-employee relationships are among the areas that can receive significant attention during USCIS review. USCIS’s current RFE guidance specifically highlights these areas as recurring sources of questions.
For employers and beneficiaries, reviewing these issues before filing can provide an opportunity to identify potential weaknesses and obtain appropriate supporting documentation.
TheDegreePeople.com reviews H-1B cases with attention to issues involving specialty occupation, wage level, education, credential evaluation, and employer-employee relationships. Reviewing these areas before filing can help ensure that the petition’s evidence is organized around the requirements that need to be established.
About Sheila Danzig
Sheila Danzig is the executive director of TheDegreePeople.com and a leading expert in foreign degree evaluations. She is widely recognized for her innovative approach to difficult cases, helping thousands of clients successfully obtain visa approvals even when facing RFEs or denials. Her expertise in USCIS requirements and commitment to providing personalized, effective solutions make her a trusted resource for professionals navigating the immigration process.
Get a Free Review of Your Case
If you’ve received an RFE, don’t wait. Sheila Danzig and TheDegreePeople.com offer a free review of your case to determine the best course of action. Our expertise has helped thousands of professionals, including H-1B applicants, secure approvals even in challenging cases.
To get your free case review, visit www.ccifree.com today.